Comedy Episodes
| Ep | Title | Final Rating |
|---|---|---|
| 154 | The Three Musketeers | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 151 | Gremlins | Classic (Disputed) |
| 149 | The Care Bears Movie | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 146 | Galaxy Quest | Classic (Unanimous) |
| 139 | Hercules | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 138 | Ever After: A Cinderella Story | Classic (Disputed) |
| 136 | The Santa Clause | Classic (Disputed) |
| 134 | The Muppet Christmas Carol | Classic (Disputed) |
| 129 | Monsters Inc. | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 127 | Robin Hood | Classic (Disputed) |
| 126 | UHF | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 123 | The Sword in the Stone | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 119 | The Emperor's New Groove | Classic (Unanimous) |
| 118 | Last Action Hero | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 116 | Toy Story | Classic (Unanimous) |
| 112 | Hook | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 110 | Aladdin | Classic (Unanimous) |
| 107 | City Slickers | Classic (Unanimous) |
| 104 | Sneakers | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 102 | Wayne's World | Classic (Disputed) |
| 99 | Young Frankenstein | Classic (Disputed) |
| 97 | Adventures in Babysitting | Draw |
| 95 | Ferris Bueller's Day Off | Classic (Disputed) |
| 94 | The Truman Show | Draw |
| 93 | The Breakfast Club | Classic (Disputed) |
| 88 | What About Bob? | Classic (Disputed) |
| 87 | Son in Law | Nostalgic (Unanimous) |
| 83 | Stay Tuned | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 81 | Uncle Buck | Classic (Unanimous) |
| 80 | The Jerk | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 75 | Major Payne | Classic (Disputed) |
| 74 | Back to the Future 2 | Classic (Unanimous) |
| 73 | Groundhog Day | Nostalgic (Unanimous) |
| 71 | Home Alone | Classic (Disputed) |
| 70 | Back to the Future | Classic (Unanimous) |
| 68 | A Goofy Movie | Classic (Unanimous) |
| 67 | Encino Man | Nostalgic (Unanimous) |
| 66 | A League of Their Own | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 65 | Can't Hardly Wait | Draw |
| 63 | Three Men and a Baby | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 61 | Short Circuit | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 60 | Pee Wee's Big Adventure | Draw |
| 56 | The Mighty Ducks | Classic (Disputed) |
| 55 | The Wizard | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 53 | ¡Three Amigos! | Classic (Unanimous) |
| 52 | Spaceballs | Classic (Disputed) |
| 51 | Bill and Ted's Excellent Adventure | Classic (Disputed) |
| 50 | Dumb and Dumber | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 44 | Beverly Hills Ninja | Tragic (Unanimous) |
| 43 | Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles | Classic (Disputed) |
| 41 | The Muppet Movie | Tragic (Disputed) |
| 38 | Maverick | Classic (Unanimous) |
| 37 | Ace Ventura: Pet Detective | Classic (Disputed) |
| 36 | Sister Act | Nostalgic (Unanimous) |
| 33 | Romancing the Stone | Draw |
| 32 | Cool Runnings | Classic (Unanimous) |
| 29 | The Mask of Zorro | Tragic (Disputed) |
| 28 | Mary Poppins | Classic (Unanimous) |
| 26 | Monty Python and the Holy Grail | Classic (Disputed) |
| 23 | Tremors | Tragic (Disputed) |
| 14 | Honey, I Shrunk the Kids | Tragic (Disputed) |
| 12 | Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home | Tragic (Disputed) |
| 9 | *batteries not included | Tragic (Unanimous) |
| 1 | Superman 3 | Classic (Disputed) |