Fantasy Episodes
| Ep | Title | Final Rating |
|---|---|---|
| 202 | Dungeons & Dragons | Tragic (Unanimous) |
| 194 | Batman Begins | Classic (Disputed) |
| 188 | Batman Returns | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 187 | How the Grinch Stole Christmas! | Classic (Disputed) |
| 184 | Bill & Ted's Bogus Journey | Tragic (Disputed) |
| 182 | Jack the Giant Killer | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 178 | Willow | Classic (Unanimous) |
| 175 | Princess Mononoke | Classic (Disputed) |
| 172 | Superman 2 | Tragic (Disputed) |
| 169 | Teen Wolf | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 167 | The Dark Crystal | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 165 | LotR: The Return of the King | Classic (Unanimous) |
| 162 | The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past | Classic (Unanimous) |
| 161 | Highlander | Classic (Disputed) |
| 160 | The Little Mermaid | Classic (Disputed) |
| 151 | Gremlins | Classic (Disputed) |
| 148 | DragonHeart | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 147 | Ewoks: Battle for Endor | Nostalgic (Unanimous) |
| 144 | Legend | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 141 | Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 137 | LotR: The Two Towers | Classic (Disputed) |
| 113 | The Flash TV Pilot | Nostalgic (Unanimous) |
| 106 | The Boy Who Could Fly | Classic (Disputed) |
| 105 | LotR: The Fellowship of the Ring | Classic (Unanimous) |
| 101 | Santa Claus The Movie | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 84 | Jumanji | Classic (Disputed) |
| 83 | Stay Tuned | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 42 | Angels in the Outfield | Nostalgic (Unanimous) |
| 28 | Mary Poppins | Classic (Unanimous) |
| 26 | Monty Python and the Holy Grail | Classic (Disputed) |
| 22 | The NeverEnding Story | Classic (Unanimous) |
| 19 | Duck Tales: The Movie | Tragic (Disputed) |
| 13 | Labyrinth | Tragic (Disputed) |
| 8 | Return to Oz | Tragic (Disputed) |
| 3 | Masters of the Universe | Tragic (Disputed) |