Romance Episodes
| Ep | Title | Final Rating |
|---|---|---|
| 152 | Grease | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 145 | Lady and the Tramp | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 144 | Legend | Nostalgic (Disputed) |
| 138 | Ever After: A Cinderella Story | Classic (Disputed) |
| 115 | Top Gun | Classic (Disputed) |
| 87 | Son in Law | Nostalgic (Unanimous) |
| 73 | Groundhog Day | Nostalgic (Unanimous) |
| 65 | Can't Hardly Wait | Draw |
| 33 | Romancing the Stone | Draw |
| 31 | The Cutting Edge | Draw |